Is storing a delimited list in a database column really that bad?

Database Database Design Database Normalization

If you have ever worked with databases, you may have come across the scenario where you need to store multiple values in a single column. One common approach is to store these values as a delimited list, such as a comma-separated list, in a single column of the database table.

While this approach may seem convenient and easy to implement, it is generally considered a bad design choice in terms of database normalization and can lead to several issues in the long run. In this article, we will discuss why storing a delimited list in a database column is considered a bad practice and explore alternative solutions.

What is database normalization?

Database normalization is the process of organizing data in a database to eliminate redundancy and improve data integrity. It involves breaking down a database into multiple related tables and defining relationships between them.

Normalization follows a set of rules, known as normal forms, to ensure the database is structured efficiently and can handle data accurately. By adhering to these rules, you can avoid data anomalies and improve database performance.

The drawbacks of storing a delimited list in a database column

Although storing a delimited list in a database column may seem like a quick and easy solution, it has several drawbacks that can cause issues down the line:

  • Lack of data integrity: Storing multiple values in a single column violates the first normal form (1NF) of database normalization, which states that each column should contain only atomic values. This can lead to data integrity issues and make it difficult to enforce constraints and perform accurate data operations.
  • Difficult data querying and manipulation: Retrieving or manipulating individual values from a delimited list requires complex string manipulation operations. This can significantly impact database performance and make it challenging to write efficient and maintainable code.
  • Data redundancy and inconsistency: Storing duplicate values in a delimited list can lead to data redundancy and inconsistency. If a value needs to be updated or deleted, it would require updating the entire delimited list, resulting in inefficient and error-prone operations.
  • Limited scalability: Storing a delimited list may work for a small number of values, but as the number of values increases, the performance and manageability of the database will suffer. It becomes difficult to maintain and scale the application with a growing amount of data.

Alternative solutions

Instead of storing a delimited list in a database column, it is recommended to follow proper database normalization principles. Here are a few alternative solutions:

1. Create a separate table:


CREATE TABLE checkboxes (
  checkbox_id INT PRIMARY KEY,
  checkbox_name VARCHAR(50)
);

CREATE TABLE user_checkboxes (
  user_id INT,
  checkbox_id INT,
  PRIMARY KEY (user_id, checkbox_id),
  FOREIGN KEY (user_id) REFERENCES users(id),
  FOREIGN KEY (checkbox_id) REFERENCES checkboxes(checkbox_id)
);

In this approach, you create a separate table for checkboxes and another table to establish a many-to-many relationship between users and checkboxes. Each checkbox is stored as a separate row in the checkboxes table, and the user_checkboxes table stores the relationship between users and checkboxes.

2. Use a JSON or XML column:


CREATE TABLE users (
  id INT PRIMARY KEY,
  checkboxes JSON
);

INSERT INTO users (id, checkboxes) VALUES (1, '[{"name": "checkbox1"}, {"name": "checkbox2"}]');
INSERT INTO users (id, checkboxes) VALUES (2, '[{"name": "checkbox1"}]');

In this approach, you can use a JSON or XML column to store the checkboxes as a structured data format. Each user can have a separate record in the users table, and the checkboxes are stored as an array or object in the JSON or XML column.

Conclusion

Storing a delimited list in a database column may seem like a quick and easy solution, but it comes with several drawbacks that can impact data integrity, performance, and scalability. It is always recommended to follow proper database normalization principles and store related data in separate tables or structured data formats.

By doing so, you can ensure better data integrity, simplify data querying and manipulation, avoid redundancy and inconsistency, and easily scale your application as the data grows.

Related Questions